Chisholm’s Choice: This voter wants migrants to be seen and heard


Instead of posting about Indian curry nights, Mannie Kaur Verma wishes the prime minister — and Australian politicians generally — would engage with migrant communities in more meaningful, less tokenistic ways.

“You wouldn’t see him, for example, sitting with a group of young Indian students and saying ‘How have you found your experience in Australia as a student? And what can we do to support you?’” she says. “I never see that on his Instagram or socials.”

An Indian-born Australian, Verma lives in Glen Waverley, a suburb in Melbourne’s southeast in the marginal seat of Chisholm. It’s a multi-generational household, home to Verma, her husband, their two children — a daughter in grade one and son in kindergarten — and her parents-in-law.

Like Verma, 4 per cent of people living in Chisholm were born in India, a share that’s double the national average. And more than half of the electorate’s residents were born in another country according to 2016 Census data.

Despite this, Verma says there’s little genuine engagement with migrant communities and their concerns by politicians.

“A shared view that a lot of migrants have is that people really only come to us and ask us questions around election times,” she says.

Morrison’s family curry nights have become a staple of the prime minister’s social media feeds and form part of his political persona. So much so that the images have fed various conspiracy theories online, and Verma herself referenced them when she took him to task on Q&A, accusing his government of abandoning Australians of Indian heritage during the COVID crisis.

Verma regards the curry posts or, say, politicians rocking up to temples for Hindu festivals as insincere. She would rather see local candidates engaging with communities on a regular basis — including outside of election campaigns — and valuing the contribution that migrants make to Australia.

“In the last two years with the students not coming, we’ve seen the difference in our economy. Literally every cafe, every restaurant is looking for workers. So we see the difference migrants make to the community but I feel we’re just not valued,” she says.

In her work as a lawyer, Verma sees the challenges many face, whether it’s the financial insecurity first-generation migrant women experience once they’ve put their careers on hold to raise children, the gaps in services for women facing domestic violence, or the lack of review rights for decisions under Australia’s migration policies.

Mannie Kaur Verma with her two children. Photo: supplied.

She says a more affordable childcare system would go a long way towards addressing bigger issues like gender equality and domestic violence, particularly for first-generation migrant women.

“I’m really privileged and really blessed that I’ve got parents that live with us, and we’ve never had to really bear that expense. But if it weren’t for them, trying to have a career as a woman, while still trying to look after kids, it can be quite difficult.

“A lot of people I talk to, they often make the decision to put their careers on hold so they can look after kids because it’s more economical … As a result, you miss out on promotions, and you’re already behind.”

For many of her clients experiencing domestic violence, she says, “a lot of the time they don’t leave because they need the financial support of the second person earning in the house. A lot of the time these women haven’t been working because they’ve been looking after kids.”

As a Labor party member, Verma is seeking a prioritisation of migrant’s rights, and insists that political parties look at reforming what she describes as an unfair and unjust migration system.

In addition to being a practicing lawyer, Verma recently completed a masters thesis on politics and policy called “A Colourful Woman’s Place in Politics”.

She wants to see more women of colour entering politics — particularly in winnable seats — but to succeed they’ll need supportive networks around them.

It’s not enough for candidates to come from diverse backgrounds; representatives should bring compassion and authenticity.

She is encouraged by the approach Carina Garland has taken since being endorsed as the Labor candidate for Chisholm last year. She says Garland held many early consultations — initially on Zoom due to Melbourne’s COVID restrictions — inviting a diverse range of people, and seeking their advice on the best ways to connect with people in the electorate.

“We need someone who’s going to be relatable to us who wants to go out and sort of connect with the community and find out what the issues are.”


This is part of a continuing series by The Citizen interviewing a cross-section of voters in the hyper-marginal seat of Chisholm, in Melbourne’s south-east. The series is co-published with